Evaluation Form

Please fill in all the informaton.

If several Authors, please use comma (,) to separate.

EVALUATION FORM
BASIC INFORMATION
Manuscript Title:
Author(s):
Reviewer:
Reviewer's Email:
EVALUATION
Please rate the following: (1=Excellent) (2=Good) (3=Fair) (4=Poor)
Originality:	1 2 3 4
Contribution to the Field:	1 2 3 4
Technical Quality:	1 2 3 4
Clarity of Presentation:	1 2 3 4
Depth of Research	1 2 3 4
Keywords:	1 2 3 4
Organization:	1 2 3 4
English:	1 2 3 4
Length:	1 2 3 4
Recommendation:	Accept in the present form Accept after minor revision Accept after major revision Reject
RIVIEWER BLIND COMMENTS TO AUTHOR
RIVIEWER CONFIDENTIAL COMMENTS TO EDITOR

Back to Top ↑

---